This study explored the characteristics one needs to possess to be an effective physical education teacher. Data was collected from an open-ended response question on a questionnaire regarding exemplary classroom teachers. Physical education teachers were subjects for this study. Eighty-eight responders, having over 20+ years of physical education teaching experience, provided answers. Data were analyzed using content analysis based on word count and content similarity. The findings show that veteran physical education teachers believe relationship building, flexibility, humanitarianism, life-long learning, and respect are characteristics that make effective physical education teachers.