References

1. 1999. Net DACdisbursementsgrewatanaverageannualrateof3percentbetween1975and2000(Coyle,2023\. Positive Impactsof Foreign Aid Evaluatingaideffectivenessin PNGrequiresspecificationofevaluativecriteria. Asaresourcetransfermechanismandprojectfinancinginstrument, aidhasregisteredmeasurablesuccess(Hnanguie,2003\. Aidfacilitatedthebridgingofinvestment-savingsgapsingrossterms, addressedforeignexchangeconstraints, andfinanceddevelopmentprojects, achievinghighinternalratesofreturn-includingschools, clinics, healthposts, bridges, roads, capacity-buildinginitiatives, andwatersupplysystems(Pryke,2019\. Duringmuchofthepost-independenceperiod, PNGrankedas Australia'slargestbilateralaidrecipient, reflectinghistoricaltiesandpovertyalleviationobjectives. Tangibleaidoutcomesarevisiblenationwide: roadandbridgeconstruction, schoolandhospitalinfrastructure, institutionalestablishment, andoverseastechnicaltrainingforthousands International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com971|Pageof Papua New Guineans(Hnanguie,2003\. Inthehealthsector, aidhasfinancedmajorinfrastructure-including Port Moresby General Hospital-andsupportederadicationcampaignsagainstsmallpoxandpolio. Fertilitydeclinesinselectedprovincesaredirectlyattributabletodonorpopulationprogrammes, particularly United Nationsinitiatives(Kabir,2020\. Theongoing HIV/AIDSresponseremainsalmostentirelyaid-funded, encompassinghealthinfrastructure, personneltraining, publicawarenesscampaigns, andinitialadvocacyeffortstosecuregovernmentcommitmenttopublichealthaction(Brown,2021\. Agriculturalaidestablishedresearchandextensionnetworkscrucialfordevelopinganddisseminatinghigh-yieldtreecropvarieties, nowintegraltonationalcroppingsystems(Kabir,2020\. Transportandinfrastructureassistancecontributedsubstantiallytoconstructingandupgradingmajorroadnetworks, includingsectionsofthe Hiritanoand Okukhighways. Acrossagriculture, livestock, fisheries, education, health, watersupply, finance, transport, andinstitutionalcapacitydevelopment, aidhasleftanindelibleimprint(Hnanguie,2003\. Humanitarianassistancemitigatedthesocialimpactsofthe1998 Aitapetsunami, facilitated Kokopo'sreconstructionfollowingthe1996volcaniceruptions, andsupported Bougainville'spost-conflictrebuildingfrom2000onward. Fromtheearly1990s, donors-ledbythe World Bank-supportedsuccessivegovernmentsinundertakingeconomicpolicyreformtoreducestateinterventionismandcreateprivate-sector-friendlypolicyenvironments(Brown,2021\. Despiteresistancefromentrenchedinterests, threedecadesofreformefforthaveyieldedsubstantialprogress. Aid-supportedreformshavefacilitatedrealisticexchangeratepolicies, improvedmonetarymanagement, widespreadderegulation, andpriceliberalisation. Whileprivatisationandinstitutionalreformremainincomplete, donor-ledreformprocesseshavedemonstrablytransformed PNG'spolicyenvironment(Tosun, Kirikkaleli,&Safakli,2020\. Negative Impactsof Foreign Aid Overthepast48years, evenostensiblypositiveachievementshaveattractedincreasingscrutiny. Theadventofstructuraladjustmentprogrammesblurredaidobjectivesandcomplicatedeffectivenessevaluation(Feeny,2023\. Theevidentiaryrecordsuggeststhatforeignaidto PNGbetween1975and2000registeredmorefailuresthansuccesses. The ADB's1998 Country Assistance Planreportedthatonlyfiveof16evaluatedprojectswereratedasgenerallysuccessful. The World Bank'sevaluationof30projectsundertakensince1968indicatedafailurerateof22percentforprojectscompletedbetween1968and1978, escalatingto60percentforpost-1978projects(Hnanguie,2003\. Thiselevatedfailurerateislargelyattributabletoinadequatecounterpartfundingandgovernmenteconomicmismanagement. Multiplefactorshaveunderminedaideffectivenessin PNG. First, aideffectivenesswascompromisedwhendonorobjectivesdivergedfrom PNG'seconomicdevelopmentpriorities. Aidmotivatedbydonorcommercialorforeignpolicyconsiderationsfrequentlyfailedtoservelocaleconomicinterests(Feeny,2023\. Suchnon-economicmotivesproducedaidactivitiespoorlytailoredto PNG'sspecificneedsandabsorptivecapacities. Second, PNG'ssocioeconomicandpoliticalenvironmentcriticallyaffectedaidoutcomes, witheconomicpolicyqualityandgovernmentalstabilityexertingdecisiveinfluence(Tosun, Kirikkaleli,&Safakli,2020\. Thegovernment'scapacitytointegrateaidwithincoherentdevelopmentstrategyandmanagementframeworksprovedessentialtoaidsuccess. Donorscannotcompensatefortheabsenceofaneffectivegovernmentequippedwithappropriatebudgetingandplanningprocesses(Feeny,2023\. Recurringaidproblemsin PNGoriginateingovernmentalfunctionalbreakdowns. Projectsustainabilityfailuresfollowingdonorresourceterminationtypicallyreflectinadequaterecurrentexpenditurebudgeting. Similarly, aidcoordinationfailures-producingoverlapping, contradictory, andredundantactivitiesstemfromgovernmentincapacitytointegratedonorassistancewithincoherentnationaldevelopmentbudgetingandplanningexercises(Hnanguie,2003\. Chronicpoliticalinstabilityandinfightinghaveinstitutionalizedcrisismanagementmodalities, wherebylong-termdevelopmentplanningandsystematicbudgetingaresupplantedbyadhocgap-filling, continuousexternalcreditornegotiation, andincreasedpoliticizationofrevenueallocation(Pryke,2019\. Overtime, soundmanagementpracticeserode, andpubliccorruptionproliferates. Persistentunder-investmentinmaintenanceandrecurrentexpendituresprogressivelyincapacitatespublicorganizations. Resource-starvedpublicmanagersandpoliticiansincreasinglylobbyforforeignaidtoaddresspressingemergencyneedsratherthanlong-termdevelopmentchallenges(Coyle,2023\. Pressedtodemonstraterapidresults, donoragenciesfrequentlycircumventthearduous, long-termtaskofdevelopingcentralgovernmentmanagementcapacities. Donorshaveexercisedcontroloverprojectidentification, design, andevaluationtocompensateforlimitedgovernmentcapacitytoundertakethesecriticalfunctions(Feeny,2023\. Manyaidprojectscontinuetobedesignedwithminimallocalinput. Donorsdeploylong-termexpatriatetechnicaladvisersratherthanrelyonlocalexpertise(Coyle,2023\. Moreperniciously, donorshaveattemptedtobypasscentralgovernmentinstitutionsentirely-establishingstand-aloneprojectstructuresandincreasinglychannelingresourcesthroughcivilsocietyandnon-governmentalorganizations(Hnanguie,2003\. Thesepracticessystematicallyunderminecapacitydevelopmentbymarginalizinggovernmentinstitutionswithinaidprocesses. Forexample, onlytwopercentofallprojectswithinthepredominantlydonor-funded Public Investment Programmehaveeverundergoneformalgovernmentevaluation(Hnanguie,2003\. Valuableopportunitiesforexperientiallearninginprojectdesignandevaluationareforfeited. Moreseriously, suchpracticeserodegovernment'ownership'overprojectsanddiminishprospectsforsustainedlong-termfinancialcommitment(Pryke,2019\. Higherlevelsofaideffectivenessareattainablewhenthegovernmentintegratesaidwithindomesticbudgetingandplanningframeworksandexercisestheprerogativetorefuseassistanceinconsistentwithnationaldevelopmentpriorities(Feeny,2023\. Foreign Aidto Fiji Fijimaintainsmultilateralandbilateralrelationshipsthroughwhichdevelopmentassistanceflowsfromdonornations(Tosun, Kirikkaleli,&Safakli,2020\. Principalbilateraldonorsinclude Japan, Australia, Germany, the United States, China, New Zealand, and Korea. Multilateralpartners International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com972|Pagecomprisethe World Bank Group, Asian Development Bank, European Union, United Nationssystem, International Fundfor Agricultural Development, and Commonwealth Fundfor Technical Cooperation(Nailatikau,2022\. Aid Volumeand Dependency Profile Fijireceivescomparativelymodestforeignaidrelativetoregionalneighbors. Averageannualaidflowsconstituteapproximatelytwopercentof Fiji'sgrossdomesticproduct(GDP\, significantlybelowcorrespondingratiosfor Samoa(35percent\, Solomon Islands(60percent\, Tonga(34percent\, and Vanuatu(25percent\(World Bank Group,2021\. Onapercapitabasis, Fijireceives US$87, substantiallylessthan Samoa(US$527\, Solomon Islands(US$612\, Tonga(US$909\, and Vanuatu(US$506\(Australian Departmentof Foreign Affairs,2023\. Fiji'saiddependencyisthusconsiderablyattenuated. Moreover, annualremittancesfromoverseasresidents-drivenbyglobalizationandincreasedprofessionalandworkermigrationhaveprogressivelyeclipsedforeignaidineconomicsignificance(Nailatikau,2022\. Contributionsto Socialand Economic Development Foreignaidhashelpedbridge Fiji'sinvestment-savingsgapsingrossterms, addressforeignexchangeconstraints, andfinancedevelopmentprojects, achievinghighinternalratesofreturn, includingschools, clinics, healthposts, bridges, roads, capacity-building, andtrainingprogrammes(Salem,2020\. Asin PNG, manyaidachievementswerecompromisedbycounterproductivegovernmenteconomicpolicies. Donorshavesupportedsuccessiveadministrationsinundertakingeconomicpolicyreformtoreducestateinterventionandcultivateprivate-sector-friendlypolicyenvironments(Ligaiula,2022\. Threedecadesofreformefforthavegeneratedsubstantialprogress. Aidhassupportedtheimplementationofrealisticexchangeratepolicies, improvedmonetarymanagement, widespreadderegulation, andpriceliberalisation. Whileprivatisationandinstitutionalreformagendasremainincomplete, donor-ledreformprocesseshavecontributedtotransforming Fiji'spolicyenvironment, socialservices, andeconomicgrowthtrajectory(Salem,2020\. Negative Impactsof Foreign Aid Professor Helen Hughesdeliveredasevereindictmentofaideffectivenessin Fiji, observingpooreconomicgrowthdespiteplentiful Westernaidandconcludingthatforeignaidhadfailedthecountry(Ligaiula,2022\. Hughesidentifiedsystemicweaknessesinaidadministration: poorprojectselection; ineffectiveimplementation; laxmonitoring; andinadequateevaluation. Shefurthercriticised Fijiangovernmentleadersformanipulatingdonorcompetitiontocaptureaidresourcesforpersonalbenefit(Salem,2020\. Thepost-9/11waronterrorismreorienteddonorpriorities. Roger Riddle, inakeynoteworkshopaddress, observedthatevaluativequestionshadshiftedoverthreedecades: fromwhetherprojectsmetimmediateinfrastructureobjectives, towhetheraidmademeasurableimpactsonpoverty, andultimatelytowhetherrecipientcountriesmighthavebeenbetteroffwithoutaidaltogether(Nailatikau,2022\. Accumulatingevidencesuggeststhatunconditionalaidflowshaveperpetuatedpovertyanddeepeneddependencysyndromes. Aidhasbeenimplicatedinsuppressingtraditionalcropexports, erodingtheinternationalcompetitivenessofdomesticallyprocessedgoods, andcontributingtorealexchangerateappreciationavariantof Dutchdiseasethatrendersexportslessattractiveininternationalmarkets(Ligaiula,2022; Nailatikau,2022\[27,. Summaryand Comparative Implications Thisreviewhasdocumentedbothconvergentanddivergentpatternsinforeignaidto Bangladeshandthe Pacific Island Countries. Acrosscases, aiddemonstratesafundamentallydualisticcharacter: capableoffinancingcriticalinfrastructure, humandevelopment, andpolicyreform, yetsimultaneouslyvulnerabletopoliticalcapture, institutionalmarginalisation, andunintendedeconomicdistortions. The Pacificcasesilluminatestructuralchallenges-aiddependency, weakabsorptivecapacity, donorfragmentation, andtheerosionoflocalownershipthatresonatewith Bangladesh'sexperience. Samoaexemplifiesthegeopoliticalinstrumentalisationofaidandaccountabilitydeficitsthatenableresourcemisappropriation. PNGprovidesextensiveevidenceofhowchronicpoliticalinstability, weakplanningsystems, anddonorpracticesthatcircumventgovernmentinstitutionssystematicallyundermineaideffectivenessandcapacitydevelopment. Fijidemonstratesthatloweraiddependencydoesnotimmuniserecipientsfromthedysfunctionsofpoorprojectselection, weakimplementation, and Dutchdiseaseeffects. Thesecomparativeinsightsinformthesubsequentanalysisof Bangladesh'saidexperience, towhichthisstudynowturns. Theconvergentchallengesidentifiedacrossthesedistinctdevelopmentalcontextsunderscoretheimperativeforsystemicreforminbothdonorpracticesandrecipientgovernanceframeworks. Withoutsuchreform, foreignaidrisksperpetuatingtheverystructuraldependenciesitpurportstoresolve. Researchmethodology Research Design Thisstudyemploysasecondaryresearchdesign, whichreferstothesystematicgatheringandsynthesisofinformationthatalreadyexistsandispubliclyavailable. Unlikeprimaryresearch, whichgeneratesnewdata, secondaryresearchutilisesdatapreviouslycollectedbyotherinvestigators, oftensubjectedtopriorstatisticalanalysis, andnotownedbythepresentresearcher(Ruggiano&Perry,2019\. Suchdataaretypicallyderivedfromprimarysourcesandsubsequentlymadeaccessibleforbroaderscholarlyandprofessionaluse. Secondarydatathusconstitutessecond-handinformation, originallygatheredbyothersfordistinctpurposes. Insecondaryresearch, existingdataaresystematicallycollated, criticallyevaluated, andsynthesisedtoenhancetheoveralleffectivenessandanalyticaldepthofthenewinvestigation. Thisresearchdrawsupondataoriginallycollectedbyotherscholarsandinstitutionsconcerningforeignaidanditspositiveandnegativeimplicationsforrecipientcountries(Cheong, Lyons, Houghton,&Majumdar,2023\. Data Sources Thedataforthisstudywerecollectedfromadiverserangeofonlinesources, including:
2. 1. Peer-reviewedacademicjournals
3. 2. Officialpolicydocumentsandgovernmentreports International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com973|Page
4. 3. Scholarlybooksandbookchapters
5. 4. Institutionalanddevelopmentagencyreports
6. 5. Newspapersandreputableperiodicals
7. 6. Magazinesandgreyliterature Thesesourceswereselectedbasedontheirrelevance, authority, andcontributiontounderstandingthemultifaceteddimensionsofforeignaid. Typesof Secondary Data Secondarydatamaybeclassifiedintotwoprincipaltypes: qualitativeandquantitative. Qualitativesecondarydataconcernintangibleattributesandencompassfactorssuchasquality, preference, perception, appearance, andcontextualmeaning(Wickham,2019\. Suchdataareessentialforexploringthenuancedexperiences, policyenvironments, andsocio-politicaldynamicsthatshapeaideffectiveness. Quantitativesecondarydatacomprisesnumericalinformation, includingstatistics, percentages, financialflows, andeconometricindicators(Wickham,2019\. Thesedataenablethemeasurementofaidvolumes, sectoralallocations, anddevelopmentaloutcomes. Thisresearchintegratesbothqualitativeandquantitativesecondarydatafromabroadarrayofonlinedocumentsanddatasets, ensuringacomprehensiveandmethodologicallybalancedinvestigation. Data Collection Procedure Datacollectionconstitutesafundamentalcomponentofanyresearchstudy. Itinvolvesthesystematicgatheringofinformationfromavailablesourcestoaddressadefinedresearchproblem(George,2023\. Theprocessenablesresearcherstoevaluatecurrentoutcomes, identifypatterns, andprojectfuturetrendsandpossibilities. Effectivedatacollectiontypicallyproceedsfromthemostfoundationalinformationrelevanttotheproblem, progressivelyexpandinginvolumeandcomplexityastheinvestigationadvances(Wickham,2019\. Twooverarchingmethodsofdatacollectionarerecognised: primaryandsecondary. Eachmethodrequirescarefulidentificationofdatatypes, sources, andappropriatecollectiontechniques. Diversecollectionmethodsareemployedacrosscommercial, governmental, andacademicresearchcontexts, withvarioussourcesaccesseddependingonwhetherprimaryorsecondarydataarebeinggathered(George,2023\. Whetherappliedtoscholarlyinquiryorpracticalproblem-solving, rigorousdatacollectionenhancesdecision-makingandimprovesresearchoutcomes. Thisstudyutilizessecondarydatacollectionexclusively, concentratingonthefieldofforeignaidassistance-particularlyflowsfromdevelopedtodevelopingnations. Datawerecollectedonmultipledimensionsofaid, including:
8. 1. Donorandrecipientperspectivesonaidobjectivesandeffectiveness
9. 2. Processesofaidnegotiation, disbursement, andimplementation
10. 3. Challengesencounteredduringtheaidlifecycle
11. 4. Advantagesanddisadvantages, includingbothintendedbenefitsandunintendedconsequences(Cheong, Lyons, Houghton,&Majumdar,2023\Insecondaryresearch, thecapacitytocollectauthenticandrelevantdataandtoformulatesolutionsthatmeetresearchobjectivesultimatelydependsupontheresearcher'sabilitytoexercisecriticalthinkingindigesting, interpreting, andsynthesizingexistinginformation. Data Analysis Secondarydataanalysisinvolvestheuseofdataoriginallygatheredbyotherresearchersandisdefinedasthereanalysisofpreviouslycollectedinformation(Wickham,2019\. Itmayalsobeunderstoodastheanalysisofdatabyresearcherswhowerenotinvolvedintheoriginaldatacollectionprocess(Ruggiano&Perry,2019\. Awidevarietyofdatasourcesareavailableforsecondaryanalysis, andtheselectionofappropriatesourcesisdeterminedbythespecificfocusandobjectivesoftheresearch(Ruggiano&Perry,2019\. Secondarydataanalysisisoneofthemostwidelyemployeddatacollectionandanalyticaltechniquesinsocialscienceresearch(Wickham,2019\. Despiteitslong-standingtraditionandcontinuedprevalence, themethodisnotwithoutitscritics. Aprincipalcriticismholdsthatsecondaryanalysisissuitableonlyforhighlyexperiencedresearchers(Cheong, Lyons, Houghton,&Majumdar,2023\. Nevertheless, notwithstandingitsinherentlimitations, secondarydataanalysisremainsaninvaluableresearchtechniquenotonlywithinthesocialsciencesbutacrossvirtuallyalldisciplines. Ruggianoand Perry(2019\contendthatitisdifficulttoconceiveofanycredibleresearchstudythatdoesnot, insomemeasure, benefitfromsecondarydataanalysis. Thisstudyundertakesasystematicandcriticalexaminationofexistingdataandinformationonforeignaid. Theanalyticalfocusencompasses:
12. 1. Theprocessesbywhichrecipientcountriessecureforeignaid
13. 2. Themodalitiesofaiddeliveryandimplementation
14. 3. Thebenefitsderivedfromaidassistance
15. 4. Thepositiveandnegativeimplicationsexperiencedbyrecipientcountries Bangladeshwaspurposivelyselectedasthecasestudyforthisinvestigation. Theanalysisexamineshowandfromwhom Bangladeshhasreceivedforeignaid, thetypesofbenefitsaccrued, theimplications-bothfavourableandadverse-encountered, andthespecificchallengesthathaveariseninthecourseofaidreceipt. Thesedataweresystematicallyanalysed, interpreted, andsynthesisedtogeneratethefindingsandconclusionspresentedinthisstudy. Ethical Considerationsin Secondary Research Althoughsecondaryresearchdoesnotinvolvedirectinteractionwithhumanparticipants, ethicalconsiderationsremainpertinent. Thisstudyensuresthatallsecondarydatasourcesareproperlyattributedandcitedinaccordancewithacademicintegritystandards. Dataareusedexclusivelyforthepurposesforwhichtheywereoriginallymadepubliclyavailable, andnomisrepresentationoftheoriginalauthors'findingsorintentionsisundertaken. Limitationsand Mitigation Strategies Secondaryresearchissubjecttocertaininherentlimitations. Theseincludetheresearcher'slackofcontroloveroriginaldataquality, potentialmismatchesbetweentheoriginaldatacollectionpurposesandthepresentresearchquestions, andthepossibilityofpublicationbiasinavailableliterature. Tomitigatetheselimitations, thisstudy: International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com974|Page
16. 1. Triangulatesfindingsacrossmultipleindependentsources
17. 2. Criticallyevaluatesthemethodologicalrigouroforiginalstudies
18. 3. Explicitlyacknowledgeswheredatalimitationsmayaffectconclusions Research Cases Review Analysis Foreignaidassistance: Acasestudyof Bangladesh Bangladeshhasbeenaforeignaidrecipientsinceitbecameindependent. Accordingtoresearchdoneontheeffectsofforeignaidin Bangladesh, therearetwodifferentviews(Sen, Islametal,2019\. Thetraditionalviewshowsthesignificantbeneficialeffectsontherecipientcountries. Itisarguedthatforeigncapitalnotonlycomplementsdomesticresourcesofthecapital-deficientcountries, butalsohelpstorelieve(Sen, Islametal,2019\. Ithelpstoaccessmoderntechnologyandmanagerialskillsintherecipientcountries. Buttheeconomicgrowthofrecipientcountriesoverthelastfourdecadesdoesnotsupporttheconventionalwisdom. Accordingto Rafiand Khan,(2021\, thereisanegativeexperienceofforeigncapitalflows. Theradicalanti-aidviewshowsthenegativeeffectofforeignaid. Itoccursduetoinappropriatetechnology, distortsdomesticincomedistribution, andleadstoacorruptgovernmentinthoserecipientcountries(Sen, Islametal,2019\. Thesetwodifferentviewsdescribetheforeignaidfromothercountriesthatisreceivedby Bangladesh. Forcollectingforeignaid, Bangladeshtakesarisklikecorruptionscomeintoplay, andpoliticalharassmentalsotakesitstoll. Therearemanytypesofhiddenagendasandstringattachtoforeignaidthat Bangladeshmustbeaware. Theseimpedimentsandhindranceswithforeignaidputalotofpressureonthe Bangladeshgovernmenttobecautiousandcarefullyusetheaidproperly(Sen, Islametal,2019\. Earlytrendofforeignaidto Bangladesh Intheearlytrendsofdevelopmentaidto Bangladesh, thecountryinthefirstthreedecadesreceivedalotofforeignaidandfinancialassistancefromothercountriessinceitsindependencein1971(Rafi&Khan,2021\. Theysaidinthelasttwodecades, thedisbursementofforeignaidincreased, causingannual GDPtoincreasetooattherateof6.15percent. Thesocialandeconomicindicators, suchastheincreaseinlifeexpectancyatbirth, increasedfrom65yearsin2001to72yearsin
19. 2019. Alongwiththat, theadolescentbirthrate(per1,000women\fellfrom109in2001to81in2019, duetoeffortstoreducethechildmarriagerateandincreasingsecondaryschoolenrollmentratesfrom51%to72%(Rafi&Khan,2021\. Theinfantmortalityrate(under5\decreasedfrom81.6(per1,000livebirths\in2001to30.8in
20. 2019. Asperthe Centrefor Policy Dialogue(CPD\Bangladesh, healthaidhasbeenasignificantdeterminantofhealthoutcomesin Bangladeshinthepasttwodecades. Accordingto Rafiand Khan(2021\, foreignaidtowardshealthhasincreasedfromapproximately USD138millionin2001to USD203millionin
21. 2018. Therefore, improvementsinthesocialindicatorscanbelargelyattributedtotheeffortsofthe Governmentof Bangladeshand Non-government Organizations, andforeignaidreceivedinsectorsthatimprovedsocialindicatorsin Bangladesh(Rafi&Khan,2021\. Thetablebelowindicatesthedisbursementofaidannual GDPgrowthof Bangladesh. Fig1: Comparisonof ODAdisbursedandtheannual GDPgrowth. beenaforeignaidrecipientcountryreceivingabout$56.5billioninforeignaidfromthedonorcountriesduringthe1971-2012period. Thisshowsthat Bangladeshhasbeenarecipientofforeignaidsincethenineties. They, likeeveryotheraidrecipientcountry, havebeendependentonaid. Bangladeshreceivesforeignassistancemainlytofinancethebudgetandtradedeficit, plustheannualdevelopmentprogram(Hossain,2014\. Theforeignassistancereceivedby Bangladeshisconstitutedmainlybygrantsandinterest-basedloans. Duringthe1971-2021period, loansoccupiedalargeportion(58.22percent\ofthetotalexternalassistance, whilegrantsmadeup41.78percentofallforeignassistance(Hossain,2014\. Thefactthattheamountofloansbythegovernmentof Bangladeshtooutsidecountriesexceedstheamountofthegrantsthatthecountryreceives. Plunging Bangladeshintodeeploansthattheyareunabletopayontime. International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com975|Page Effectoflabormigrationon Bangladesh Labormigrationhaslongbeenaprominentpovertyalleviationanddevelopmentstrategyfor Bangladeshsinceitsindependencein1971(Ahmed, Islam&Moniruzzaman,2025\. Thisisanotherformofaidfromforeigncountriesthatisprovidedto Bangladeshiwomen. Thisistoalleviatepovertyindevelopingcountries, especiallyfamiliesthatarebelowthepovertyline. Annually, aroundhalfamillion Bangladeshisleavethecountrytoworkoverseas, andtheremittancessentbythemigrantsispivotalfor Bangladesh'sbeenaconsistentgrowthinremittances, andin2020, itstandsat$21.75billion-anincreaseof18.4%from
22. 2019. Internationalremittanceaccountedfor6.6%of Bangladesh's GDPin2020, placingitattheeighthpositionamongthelargestremittance-receivingcountriesoftheworld, whichunderlinestheimportanceoflabormigrationin Bangladesh(Ahmed, Islam&Moniruzzaman,2025\. Remittancesarethemoneythatisearnedby Bangladeshimigrantlabourersandissentbackhometodeveloptheirfamiliesthatarebackhomein Bangladesh. Thisfinancialassistanceverymuchhelped Bangladeshfamiliestomeettheirsocialneedslikefood, water, clothing, schoolfees, medicalcosts, andotherhouseholdneeds. Thepandemicfrom2019-2021putapauseonthismigrationlaboursinmanyregionsandcountriesaroundtheworld, withnoexceptionto Samoa. Duetotheclosingofbordersallaroundtheworld, thenumberoflabourimmigrantshasdropped. Forexample, Bangladesh'sdecreaseof69%insendinglabourforcesoverseascomparedto2018, theyearbeforethepandemic. Whilein2019, morethan700,000 Bangladeshimigrantsmigratedasguestworkers, thisfiguredroppedto217,669in2020(see Table1\. Inthecaseofwomen'smigration, thedropinstatisticsisevenhigher. Atotalof21,934femaleworkersmigratedfrom Bangladeshasguestworkersin2020, whichwas104,786in2019almostfourtimeshigherandfellby79%comparedwiththepreviousyear(see Table2\(Ahmed, Islam&Moniruzzaman,2025\. Fig2: Year-wiseinternationallabormigrationfrom Bangladesh(20112020\Fig3: Year-wiseoverseasemploymentofwomenmigrantsfrom Bangladesh(20112020\International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com976|Page Thefirsttableshowstheinternationallabourmigrationforallthemigrantlaborersintheyears2011-2020, andthesecondtableshowstheyear-wiseoverseasemploymentofwomenmigrantsfrom Bangladeshfromtheyears2011-
23. 2022. Thestatisticsintableoneshowsthatthenumberofmigrantlaborersfromthebeginningwasnotasteadyflow; itwentupin2011-2012andfluctuatedin2013-
24. 2015. Itspeakyearwas
25. 2017. However, itfluctuatedagainin2020withthelowestnumberofmigrantlaborersduetotheriseofthe COVID-19pandemic. Table2showsthestatisticsofwomenmigrantsfrom Bangladesh. Itstartedwiththelowestnumberofwomenmigrantsin2011, anditincreasedslowlyafterwards. Itspeakpointwas2016-2017; however, in2020, itdroppedlowerthanthestartingpointbecauseofthe COVID-19pandemic(Ansar,2022\. Duringthesameperiod, Bangladeshhasalsoreceivedarecordnumberofreturneemigrantsowingtojobloss, arbitrarydismissal, andforceddeportation. Accordingtothe Bangladesh Ministryof Expatriate Welfareand Overseas Employment, atotalof408,000migrantworkersreturnedtothecountryin
26. 2020. Thus, around2000migrantworkersreturnedto Bangladeshdailysincethepandemic'sbeginning. Overviewof Foreign Aidto Bangladesh Bangladesh, asadevelopingcountry, maintainsextensivemultilateralandbilateralrelationshipswithdonorgovernmentsandinternationalfinancialinstitutions. Sincegainingindependencein1971, thenationhasbeenaconsistentrecipientofforeignaidandremainssubstantiallyreliantonexternalassistanceacharacteristicitshareswithmanydevelopingeconomies(Sen, Islametal.,2019\. Thesediplomaticanddevelopmentalpartnershipshavefacilitatedsignificantinflowsofdevelopmentassistancefromdevelopednations, directedtowardfosteringsocialandeconomicgrowth. Theimpactofforeignaidon Bangladesh'sdevelopmenttrajectoryissubstantialandmultifaceted. Aidhasfinancedextensiveinfrastructuredevelopmentandsectoralprojectsacrossagriculture, livestock, fisheries, education, health, watersupply, finance, transport, andsocioeconomicinfrastructure, inadditiontosupportinginstitutionalcapacitybuildingandtrainingprogrammes. Hossain(2014\documentsthat Bangladeshreceivedapproximately US$56.5billioninforeignaidfromdonorcountriesduringthe19712012period, resourcesthatunderpinnedconsiderableinfrastructureexpansionandsocialservicedeliverytothe Bangladeshipopulation. Challengesand Adverse Impactsin Bangladesh Notwithstandingthesedevelopmentalcontributions, foreignaidto Bangladeshhasbeenaccompaniedbysignificantchallenges, resistance, andunintendednegativeconsequences. The COVID-19pandemic, forinstance, precipitatedsubstantialdisruptionstoaid-fundedprojectsandactivities. Ansar(2022\highlightstheseverecontractioninwomen'soverseasemploymentasanillustrativecase: thenumberoffemalemigrantworkersfrom Bangladeshplummetedfrom104,786in2019tojust21,934in2020-adeclineofapproximately79percent. Thisdramaticreductionnotonlydiminishedremittanceflowsbutalsoexposedthevulnerabilityofaid-dependentdevelopmentstrategiestoexogenousshocks. Comparative Analysis: The Pacific Region Theexperiencesof Bangladeshfindstrongresonanceinthe Pacificregion, wheresmallislandstates-including Samoa, Papua New Guinea(PNG\, and Fiji-havelikewisereceivedsubstantialdevelopmentassistancefromdevelopednationstoadvancesocialandeconomicinfrastructure. Papua New Guinea: Hnanguie(2003\observesthattherelativelylargevolumeofforeignaidflowinginto PNGsince1975hascontributedmeasurablytonationaldevelopment. Sectoralgainsparallelthoseobservedin Bangladesh, encompassingagriculture, livestock, fisheries, education, health, watersupply, finance, transport, socioeconomicinfrastructure, andinstitutionalcapacitybuilding. Samoa: Mata'afa-Tufele(2021\reportsthatforeignaidto Samoahasstimulatedeconomicgrowth, strengthenedcriticaleconomicinfrastructureresilience, andimprovedtheregulatoryenvironmentforbusinessandinternationaltrade-reformsexplicitlydesignedtosupportandsustaineconomicexpansion. Fiji: Nailatikau(2022\similarlyemphasisesthatforeignaidhassupported Fiji'ssocialandeconomicdevelopment, withfinancialassistancedirectedtowardincome-generatingactivities, povertyreductioninitiatives, andinstitutionalcapacitybuilding. Divergent Outcomesandthe Questionof Effectiveness Theeffectivenessofforeignaidacrossthesecontextsremainscontested. As Brown(2021\notes, evaluativeconclusionsdependfundamentallyuponthecriteriaapplied. Asaresourcetransfermechanismandprojectfinancinginstrument, aidhasregisteredmeasurablesuccesses. However, whenassessedagainstbroaderdevelopmentalbenchmarks, therecordisdecidedlymixed. Governanceand Administrative Weaknesses Allthree Pacific Islandnations, like Bangladesh, haveencounteredpersistentchallengesinsecuringandimplementingaid. Theseincludegovernmentalmishandlingofaidfunds, programmemanagementdeficiencies, andworkforceskilldeficitsthatconstraincapacitytomanageandexecutelarge-scaleinfrastructureprojects. Ligaiula(2022\identifiessystemicweaknessesin Fiji'saidadministration: poorprojectselection, ineffectiveimplementation, laxmonitoringofprogress, andinadequateevaluationprotocols. Morecritically, Salem(2020\documentsinstanceswhere Fijiangovernmentleadersengagedinstrategicmanipulationofdonorcompetition-playingonedonoragainstanother-tocaptureaidresourcesforpersonalbenefitratherthandevelopmentalpurposes. Project Failure Rates Theempiricalrecordfrom PNGisparticularlysobering. Hnanguie(2003\reportsthatof16 Asian Development Bank-assistedprojectsevaluated, onlyfivewereratedasgenerallysuccessful. World Bankprojectperformancesimilarlydeterioratedovertime: projectscompletedbetween1968and1978registeredafailurerateof22percent, whichescalatedto60percentforprojectscompletedafter
27. 1978. International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com977|Page Thispatternofdecliningaideffectivenesscorrespondscloselywithgovernancedeteriorationandeconomicmismanagementdocumentedin Bangladeshandelsewhere. Economic Distortions Samoaexemplifiestheparadoxicaleconomicconsequencesofaidinflows. Mata'afa-Tufele(2021\explainsthatincreasedimportcapacity-fueledbyaid-financedpurchasingpower-hasinflatedlocalpricesforgoodsandservices. Asdemandpressuresexceeddomesticsupplycapacity, pricesrisedisproportionately. Smallenterprisesoperatingatdiseconomiesofscalestruggletoremaincompetitiveinthisenvironment, whilelargerfirmscapableofachievingeconomiesofscalecapturedisproportionatebenefits. Thisdynamicillustratesthedistributionalinequitiesthataidcaninadvertentlygenerate. Convergent Patterns Across Contexts Table1: Thecomparativeanalysisrevealsseveralconvergentpatternsbetween Bangladeshandthe Pacific Island Countries Dimension Bangladesh Pacific Island Countries Sectoralachievements Agriculture, health, education, infrastructure, andcapacitybuilding Agriculture, health, education, infrastructure, andcapacitybuilding Governancechallenges Corruption, weakimplementation, andpoliticalinterference Corruption, weakprojectselection, inadequatemonitoring, andpoliticalmanipulation Economicdistortions Inflation, dependency, andprojectdelays Dutchdiseaseeffects(Fiji\localpriceinflation(Samoa\anddebtburdens Exogenousshocks COVID-19disruptiontomigrationandremittances Climatevulnerability, globaleconomicvolatility Donorpractices Conditionalities, tiedaid, andexpatriatereliance Parallelstructures, limitedlocalownership, andexpatriatetechnicaladvisers Discussion The Paradoxof Development Assistance Thisinterpretiveanalysisexaminesthecomplexandoftencontradictoryroleofforeignaidin Bangladesh'sdevelopmenttrajectory, drawingcomparativeinsightsfrom Pacific Islandnations. Theresearchcasestudiespresentafundamentalparadox: despitedecadesofsubstantialdevelopmentassistanceandmeasurableimprovementsincertainsocialindicators, theoveralleffectivenessofforeignaidremainsdeeplycontested. Thisdiscussioninterpretsthesefindingsthroughmultipleanalyticallenses-politicaleconomy, institutionaltheory, andpost-developmentperspectives-tounderstandwhyaidoutcomesdivergesosignificantlyfromintendedobjectives. Theresearch'sattentiontolabourmigrationintroducesanalternativeconceptualizationofforeignassistance. Unlikeofficialdevelopmentassistance, whichischannelledthroughgovernmentsandinternationalinstitutions. Ashighlightedby Ahmed, Islam&Moniruzzaman(2025\, remittancesrepresentdirecttransfersfrommigrantworkerstotheirfamilies. Thisformofassistanceoperatesthroughdifferentmechanisms, withdistinctimplicationsforpovertyalleviationandhouseholdwelfare. Traditionalversus Radical Interpretations Theresearchestablishesadialecticaltensionbetweentraditionalandradicalviewsofforeignaid. Thetraditionalperspective, groundedinneoclassicaleconomictheory, positsthatforeigncapitaladdressessavings-investmentgaps, facilitatestechnologytransfer, andsuppliesmanagerialexpertiseunavailabledomestically. Thisinterpretationtreatsdevelopingcountriesascapital-deficientsystemsinwhichexternalresourcescanbehelpful. Bangladesh'searlydevelopmentplanningexplicitlyembracedthislogic, withforeignaidpositionedascomplementarytodomesticresources(Husain,2018\. However, theempiricalevidenceresistssuchastraightforwardinterpretation. Theradicalanti-aidviewchallengesthismechanisticunderstanding, suggestingthataid'snegativeconsequences-inappropriatetechnologyadoption, distortedincomedistribution, andentrenchedcorruption-arenotmerelyimplementationfailuresbutsystematicoutcomesofaiddependencyitself. Thisperspectiveresonateswithdependencytheory, whicharguesthatexternalresourceflowsreproduceratherthanresolveunderdevelopmentbyintegratingrecipienteconomiesintoglobalhierarchiesonunfavourableterms. The Implementation Gap Acriticalinterpretivelensrevealsthataideffectivenessisfundamentallyaninstitutionalquestion. Theresearchdocumentssystematicweaknessesacrossboth Bangladeshand Pacific Islandcontexts: poorprojectselection, ineffectiveimplementation, laxmonitoring, andinadequateevaluationprotocols. Thesearenotrandomfailuresbutpatternedoutcomesreflectinginstitutionalcapacityconstraints, governancedeficits, andthemisalignmentbetweendonorrequirementsandrecipientrealities. The World Bank'sprojectfailureratein PNG, escalatingfrom22%(1968-1978\to60%(post-1978\alongsidegovernancedeterioration, powerfullyillustratesthisinstitutionalmediation. Aiddoesnotoperateinavacuumbutflowsthroughexistinginstitutionalarchitecturesthatshapeitsdeploymentandimpactasreaffirmedby Ullah, Ibrahim&Islam,
28. 2025. Whereinstitutionsareweak, captured, ormisalignedwithdevelopmentalobjectives, evenwell-designedaidprogrammesunderperform. The Samoacase-whereaid-financedimportcapacityinflateslocalprices, disadvantagingsmallenterprises-illustratestheeconomicdistortionsthataccompanyresourceinflows. Thisphenomenon, analogousto Dutchdiseaseinresource-richeconomies, occurswhenexternalinflows(Delamou,2025\appreciaterealexchangeratesorinflatenon-tradedgoodsprices, underminingthecompetitivenessofdomesticproducers(Behzadan&Chisik,2024; Nguyen Phuc, Nguyen Vietetal,2024\Interpretingthisdynamicrequiresattentiontothestructuraltransformationthataidismeanttoenableversusthetransformationsitactuallyproduces. Ratherthancatalysingproductivediversification, aidmayinadvertentlyreinforce International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com978|Pagedependenceonimportsandexternalfinancing, creatingeconomiesstructuredaroundaidreceiptratherthanproductivetransformation. Principal-Agent Problemin Aid Relationships Interpretingthesepatternsthroughprincipal-agenttheoryilluminatesthestructuraltensionsinherentinaidrelationships. Donors(principals\delegateimplementationtorecipientgovernments, NGOs, andotheractors(agents\whoseinterestsmaydivergefromdonorobjectives. Accordingto Abate(2022\, informationasymmetries, monitoringdifficulties, andcompetingaccountabilitystructurescreatespacesforslippagebetweenintentandoutcome. Theresearchidentifiesmultiplemanifestationsofthisprincipal-agentproblem: governmentalmishandlingofaidfunds, programmemanagementdeficiencies, andthedocumentedinstanceof Fijianleadersmanipulatingdonorcompetitionforpersonalbenefit(Salem,2020\. Thesebehavioursarenotmerelyindividualmalfeasancebutrationalresponsestoincentivestructuresthatrewardaidcaptureoverdevelopmentaloutcomes. Aid, Sovereignty, and Conditionality Theresearchimplicitlyraisesquestionsabouttherelationshipbetweenaidreceiptandnationalsovereignty. Thereferencetohiddenagendasandstringattachmentssuggeststhataidrelationshipsembodypowerasymmetriesthatconstrainrecipientpolicyautonomy. Bangladesh, likeotheraid-dependentnations, mustnavigateconditionalitiesthatmaynotalignwithdomesticprioritiesordevelopmentalphilosophiesashighlightedby Uddin(2024\. Thisdynamicisparticularlysalientinthe Pacificcontext, wheresmallislandstatesfacepronouncedpowerimbalancesinnegotiationswithlargerdonors. Theexpatriatetechnicaladvisersandparallelimplementationstructuresdocumentedacrosscasesrepresentnotmerelytechnicalassistancebuttheinstitutionalizationofexternalcontroloverdevelopmentprocesses. Corruptionas Systemic Theresearchidentifiescorruptionasapersistentchallengeacrossallcasesexamined. However, aninterpretiveanalysissuggestsunderstandingcorruptionnotasanindividualmoralfailingbutasasystemicoutcomeofaidrelationshipsthemselves. Whenaidflowsexceedinstitutionalabsorptivecapacity, whenaccountabilitymechanismsareexternallyimposedratherthanlocallyowned, andwhenaidcreatesrent-seekingopportunitieswithoutcorrespondinginstitutionalconstraints, corruptionbecomespredictableratherthanexceptional. Hossain(2021\statedthat Bangladesh'sexperienceofforeignaidcorruptionscomeintoplayexemplifieshowaidcaninadvertentlystrengthenextractiveratherthanproductivestate-societyrelations. Thisinterpretationalignswithpoliticaleconomyanalysessuggestingthataiddependencemayunderminethedevelopmentofdomesticaccountabilityrelationshipsbetweencitizensandstates. Convergent Patterns, Divergent Contexts Thecomparativeanalysisrevealsstrikingparallelsbetween Bangladeshand Pacific Islandnationsdespitevastlydifferentgeographic, cultural, andhistoricalcontexts. Highlightedby Roborgh, Banksetal(2025\thatbothexperiencesectoralachievementsalongsidegovernancechallenges, economicdistortionsalongsideinfrastructuredevelopment, andvulnerabilitytoshocksalongsideresilienceincertaindomains. Thisconvergencesuggeststhataideffectivenesspatternstranscendspecificnationalcharacteristics, reflectingstructuralfeaturesofaidrelationshipsthemselves. Whereinstitutionalcapacityisweak, whereaccountabilityrunsupwardtodonorsratherthandownwardtocitizens, andwhereaidcreateseconomicdistortionsthrough Dutchdiseaseorinflation, similarproblemsemergeregardlessofcontext. Beyond Binary Assessments Thisinterpretiveanalysissuggestsmovingbeyondbinaryassessmentsofaidaseithereffectiveorineffective, beneficialorharmful. The Bangladeshcasedemonstratesthataidcansimultaneouslyachievesectoralsuccesseswhilegeneratingsystemicdistortions, improvesocialindicatorswhileundermininginstitutionaldevelopment, andenablepovertyreductionwhilecreatingnewvulnerabilities. Thissimultaneitydemandsanalyticalframeworkscapableofholdingcontradiction. Ratherthanaskingwhetheraidworks, wemightask: Underwhatconditions, throughwhatmechanisms, andforwhomdoesaidproduceparticularoutcomes?Howdoaidrelationshipsinteractwithexistinginstitutionalconfigurations, politicalsettlements, andsocialstructurestogeneratedivergenteffectsacrosssectorsandpopulations?Conclusion Thisinterpretiveanalysisyieldsseveralimplicationsfordevelopmentpolicyandpractice. First, institutionalstrengtheningmustprecedeoraccompanyresourcetransfers; aidcannotsubstitutefordomesticcapacitybutmustbuildit. Second, accountabilitymechanismsshouldruninmultipledirections-todonorsandcitizens, andhorizontallyamongimplementingactors-ratherthanprivilegingaccountabilitytofunders. Third, aidrelationshipsshouldbestructuredtoenhanceratherthanunderminerecipientautonomy, recognizingthatsovereigntyisnotmerelyanormativeprinciplebutadevelopmentalprerequisite. Finally, thevulnerabilitiesexposedbythepandemicsuggesttheneedfordevelopmentmodelsthatbuildresilienceratherthandependence. Thismeansdiversifyingexternalengagements, strengtheningdomesticproductivecapacity, andensuringthatintegrationintoglobalsystemsdoesnotforeclosealternativedevelopmentpathways. For Bangladesh, for Pacific Islandnations, andforaidrecipientseverywhere, thechallengeisnottoacceptorrejectaidbuttotransformtherelationshipsthroughwhichitflows. References
29. 1. Abate CA. Istoomuchforeignaidacurseorblessingtodevelopingcountries?Heliyon.2022;8(9\: e10463. doi:10.1016/j. heliyon.2022. e10463.
30. 2. Asian Development Bank. Pacificapproach,20212025: ADB'sworkin Samoa. Manila: Asian Development Bank;
31. 2021. Availablefrom: https://www. adb. org/countries/samoa/overview
32. 3. Ahmed F, Islam MM, Moniruzzaman M. Theimpactofreturneemigrants'remittancesonreducinghouseholdinequalityandpovertyin Bangladesh: amicro-levelstudy. Rev Dev Econ.2025;29(3\:1393-1415.
33. 4. Australian Departmentof Foreign Affairsand Trade. Samoaaidprogramperformancereport
34. 201819. International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com979|Page Canberra: DFAT;
35. 2018. Availablefrom: https://www. dfat. gov. au/about-us/publications/Pages/samoa-aid-program-performance-report-2018-
36. 195. Australian Departmentof Foreign Affairsand Trade. developmentpartnershipwith Samoa. Canberra: DFAT;
37. 2023. Availablefrom: https://www. dfat. gov. au/geo/samoa/development-assistance
38. 6. Australian Departmentof Foreign Affairsand Trade. partnershipwith Fiji. Canberra: DFAT;
39. 2023. Availablefrom: https://www. dfat. gov. au/geo/fiji/development-assistance/development-partnership-with-fiji
40. 7. Bangladesh Pratidin. Japan's SMBCaccusedofworseningclimaterisksin Bangladesh. Bangladesh Pratidin.2025 May22.
41. 8. Behzadan N, Chisik R. Theparadoxoftransfers: distributionandthe Dutchdisease. South Econ J.2024;91(3\:1140-1175.
42. 9. Brown S. Theimpactof COVID-19ondevelopmentassistance. Int J.2021;76(1\:42-54. doi:10.1177/0020702020986888.
43. 10. Centerfor Global Development. Aidisn'tfairydust: long-termchangesandthelessonsofthepastdecade. Washington(DC\: Centerfor Global Development;2025 Nov13.
44. 11. Cheong H, Lyons A, Houghton R, Majumdar A. Secondaryqualitativeresearchmethodologyusingonlinedatawithinthecontextofsocialsciences. Int JQual Methods.2023;22. doi:10.1177/16094069231180160.
45. 12. Corporate Finance Institute. Foreignaid. Corporate Finance Institute;2024.
46. 13. Coyle N. Australianeedstorethink Papua New Guineaaid: peopleneedpowerandwater, notgovernanceworkshops. The Guardian.2023 Jan11.
47. 14. Dayant A. Followthemoney: howforeignaidspendingtellsof Pacificpriorities. Lowy Institute;2019 Apr17.
48. 15. Delamou CC. Curingthe Dutchdisease: theroleoftariffs. JGov Econ.2025;18:100147. doi:10.1016/j. jge.2025.100147.
49. 16. Dornan M, Pryke J. Foreignaidtothe Pacific: trendsanddevelopmentsinthetwenty-firstcentury. Asia Pac Policy Stud.2017. doi:10.1002/app5.185.
50. 17. Duke R, Dayant A, Ahsan N, Rajah R. Pacificaidmap:2025keyfindings. Sydney: Lowy Institute;2025 Oct27.
51. 18. Dziedzic S. Donorsdigdeeptopropup Pacificeconomiesleftreelingbythedireconsequencesof COVID. ABCNews.2022 Oct31.
52. 19. Feeny S. Whatdeterminesforeignaidto Papua New Guinea?Aninter-temporalmodelofaidallocation. Helsinki: World Institutefor Development Economics Research;2023.
53. 20. George T. Whatissecondaryresearch?Definition, types,&examples. Scribbr;2023 Jun22.
54. 21. Hnanguie CT. Thefutureofforeignaidin Papua New Guineaafter25yearsofsuccessesandfailures?Papua New Guinea Books;
55. 2003. Availablefrom: http://www. pngbuai. com
56. 22. Hossain N. Reflectionson Bangladeshat
57. 50. Contemp South Asia.2021;29(4\:495-499. doi:10.1080/09584935.2021.1997919.23. andneoliberalimperatives: acase-studyofprivate-sectordevelopmentin Bangladesh. Dev Policy Rev.2018;36: O803-O814.
58. 24. Kabir MA. Foreignaideffectiveness: evidencefrompaneldataanalysis. Glob JEmerg Mark Econ.2020;12(3\:283-302. doi:10.1177/0974910120961570.
59. 25. Khan MMI. Theinterimhaslittletoshowinforeignaidgovernance. The Daily Star.2026 Jan14.
60. 26. Khatun F. Foreignaidslowsasloanpressurerises. Dhaka: Centrefor Policy Dialogue;2025 Jul28.
61. 27. Ligaiula P. Australiatoprovideadditionalsupportto Fiji. Pacific News Service;2022 Mar
62. 15. Availablefrom: https://pina. com. fj/2023/03/15/australia-to-provide-additional-support-to-fiji/
63. 28. Lowy Institute. The Pacificwillendure USaidcuts, but Chinawinsnarrativeadvantage. Sydney: Lowy Institute;2025 Nov19.
64. 29. Mata'afa-Tufele T. Grants, aidcouldassist Samoa'srecovery: expert. Samoa Observer.2021 Oct6.
65. 30. Nailatikau M. Wherethebuckstops: aidin Fiji. Sydney: Lowy Institute;2022 Oct
66. 30. Availablefrom: https://www. lowyinstitute. org/the-interpreter/where-buck-stops-aid-fiji
67. 31. Nguyen PH, Nguyen VD, Le TKX, Nguyen VC, Nguyen VM. Doesofficialdevelopmentassistance(ODA\causethe Dutchdiseaseindevelopingcountries?Int JSoc Econ.2024; ahead-of-print. doi:10.1108/IJSE-12-2022-0777.
68. 32. Planning&Development Board, Punjab. Foreignassistance. Lahore: Governmentof Punjab.
69. 33. Pryke J. Thecuriouscaseofaidconcentrationin Papua New Guinea. Sydney: Lowy Institute;2019 Feb
70. 14. Availablefrom: https://www. lowyinstitute. org/the-interpreter/curious-case-aid-concentration-papua-new-guinea
71. 34. Rafi KM, Khan FH. Foreignaidto Bangladesh: athingofthepast?Dhaka: Light Castle Analytical Wing;2021 Jun
72. 14. Availablefrom: https://www. lightcastlebd. com/insights/2021/06/foreign-aid-bangladesh/
73. 35. Roborgh S, Banks N, Islam MA, Morshed KAM, Oberreit J. BRACin Bangladeshandbeyond: bridgingthehumanitariandevelopmentnexusthroughlocalisation. Dev Pract.2024;34(2\:238-252. doi:10.1080/09614524.2023.2273756.
74. 36. Ruggiano N, Perry TE. Conductingsecondaryanalysisofqualitativedata: shouldwe, canwe, andhow?Qual Soc Work.2019;18(1\:81-97. doi:10.1177/1473325017700701.
75. 37. Salem S. Chineseforeignaidto Fiji: threatoropportunity. China Report.2020;56(2\:242-258. doi:10.1177/0009445520916875.
76. 38. Stevens R. Breakingdowntheforeignaidbehemoth: theunevendevelopmentpathsof South Asiannations. Australian Instituteof International Affairs;2025 Feb25.
77. 39. The Financial Express. Thefutureofmegaprojectsfundedby JICAremainsclouded. The Financial Express.2025 Nov3.
78. 40. Tosun E, Kirikkaleli D, Safakli OV. Anisolatedislandeconomyanalysisontheeffectivenessofforeignaid: TRNC. SAGEOpen.2020;10(2\. doi:10.1177/
79. 2158244020924376. International Journalof Multidisciplinary Researchand Growth Evaluationwww. allmultidisciplinaryjournal. com980|Page
80. 41. Uddin MR. Theroleofthedigitaleconomyin Bangladesh'seconomicdevelopment. Sustain Technol Entrep.2024;3(1\:100054. doi:10.1016/j. stae.2023.100054.
81. 42. Ullah AKMA, Ibrahim K, Islam M. Foreignaidinglobaldevelopment: empowermentorentrapment?Alternatives(Glo Loc Polit\2025;0(0\. doi:10.1177/03043754251379159.
82. 43. Wickham RJ. Secondaryanalysisresearch. JAdv Pract Oncol.2019;10(4\:395-
83. 400. Availablefrom: https://www. ncbi. nlm. nih. gov/pmc/articles/PMC7520737/44. partnershipframeworkfor Fiji(20212024\. Washington(DC\: World Bank;2021 Jan
84. 29. Availablefrom: https://www. worldbank. org/en/country/pacificislands/brief/world-bank-groups-new-country-partnership-framework-for-fiji-2021-2024